...and it’s a nice machine…. now that Sony has fixed most of their messup with the original launch. I got the new European 80GB console that unlike the original US 80GB console doesn’t play PS2 games. But it is the first console to be released with a DualShock 3 controller in Europe, and apparently it’s more quiet than the first generation of consoles. And I can understand that, because if you can hear anything from the old PS3’s, they’re automatically louder than this one. I have to more or less put my ear to it to hear it.
Also, everybody else who got a PS3, my PSN id is holybork.
Anyhow, since I’ve had a 360 since release, it’s obvious I have to compare them side to side:
Noise: The 360 is awful, not only does it outnoise the PS3 and just about anything else in my livingroom, even its its external power supply is louder than the PS3.
Controller: The DualShock is a classic… bordering on too classic. While it has slightly better face buttons and D-pad than the 360, it’s not as ergonomic and its triggers are phased inwards, making them pretty easy to slip off. I personally also prefer the 360’s asymmetric stick position.
Interface: The PS3 interface is nice and clean, but slow. You can definitely see what the upcoming 360 interface got its layout from though. The 360 interface is cluttered but fast… so I’d call this a draw. I personally think the PS3 one is easier on the eye… but whatever. 1-1 still.
Online: Not having played either online yet or on ages, I can just mention that I have been disconnected from PSN at least once a day since getting it. The online interface still feels like in a prototype state. Live scores on quality, but PS3 evens it out by being free. oth are still evolving as well, so it’ll be fun to follow.
Game Installs: Should not exist if they don’t do anything substantial, which they don’t seem to do for most of the games using it. Merely keeping at seconds shorter than the Xbox version. What’s even worse, you need to install demos after downloading them on the PS3. Having lots of HD space free now makes me not care too much, but it feels pointless in some titles.
Wireless built in: Now I have no gripes with having a wire to the 360 since it resides just under the AirPort Base Station… but it’s nice to have the option.
Graphics: Most cross-platform games looks better on the 360. This is not because the PS3 is weaker, but different. Like the PS2, just getting FSAA active seems to be a bitch, since so few developers have managed in cross-platform titles. The games that have hacked a bit deeper in the PS3’s odd language fares a lot better though, and Burnout Paradise for one looks better than it did on the 360, mostly because my launch 360 does not have HDMI and the PS3 does I think though
New games is getting less difference between the consoles though, so I’ll probably keep on buying crossplatform games for PS3 for having them on the quiet machine with HDMI.
Movies: My 360 suck at movies. Not only does it whine too loud compared to anything else I could use to play a DVD on, but it butchers the image quality completely as well. It puts heavy banding across the full screen, and I’ve never been able to stand more than 10 minutes of it before shutting it down in panic. The PS3 on the other hand is orgasmic. It’s quiet, it plays Blu-Rays and it upscales DVD and does a great job of it. My DVDs has never looked this good before, and Blu-Ray is even better. No contest at all there really. But then Blu-Ray is part of the reason I got the PS3.
Exclusives: I’m leaning towards the 360 on exclusive titles, but I’d lie if I said the PS3 ones doesn’t interest me. I want to play the old ones I’ve missed out on, like MGS4, Uncharted, Ratchet & Clank, Heavenly Sword, Full Auto 2 (already have it and played it for a bit, but right now It’s mainly Burnout Paradise and Civ Rev that runs), and a lot of the PSN titles.
All in all I can’t recommend either over the other, and I could not get rid of either myself now after getting both
If noise avoidance is your thing, the PS3 is the king though. Hands down.
